Skip to content
← All resources

Daycare Operations

Catering vs. Cooking In-House: What Daycares Should Consider

2026-07-10 · 7 min read

Illustration of a balance scale weighing a cooking pot against a delivery container

An honest comparison of cost, staffing, risk and flexibility — including the situations where cooking in-house is still the better choice.

This is a real decision with real trade-offs, and the honest answer is that it depends on your size, your building and your staffing. Here is how to work it out.

Count the full cost of cooking in-house

Most centres compare a caterer's per-meal price against their grocery bill. That is not the comparison. The in-house cost includes:

  • Cook's wages, benefits, vacation and sick coverage
  • Groceries, including waste and price swings
  • Kitchen equipment, repairs and replacement
  • Utilities for a commercial kitchen
  • Time your supervisor spends planning menus and shopping
  • The cost of pulling staff from rooms when the cook is away

Where in-house genuinely wins

If you already have a well-equipped kitchen, a reliable long-term cook, and more than about eighty children, in-house is often cheaper per meal and gives you total control over the menu.

It also wins when your families have highly specific cultural food expectations that you can meet better than any supplier.

Where catering genuinely wins

Catering usually wins for centres under about sixty children, for centres without a full commercial kitchen, and for anyone who has spent a year struggling to keep a cook.

It also removes a category of risk: menu compliance, food safety records, allergy substitutions and staffing gaps all become someone else's job.

Questions to ask any caterer before you switch

  • Is the facility nut-free, or only the recipes?
  • What time does food arrive, and what is the temperature on arrival?
  • Can we see a four-week menu with a full ingredient list?
  • How are allergy substitutions cooked, packed and labelled?
  • What is the notice period for headcount changes?
  • Who do we call when something goes wrong, and will we get the same person?
  • Is hot-holding equipment provided?
  • Can we try a week before committing?

A middle path most centres miss

You do not have to choose all or nothing. Plenty of centres cook lunch themselves and cater snacks, or cater lunch and keep breakfast in-house. Splitting the load often solves the staffing problem without giving up the parts of cooking you value.

The Tiny Tummies kitchen team

We cook and deliver meals for childcare centres across the GTA every weekday. Have a question about your centre's menu? Call (647) 221-4333 or email hello@tinytummies.ca.

Get our new menus in your inbox every month.

Ready to talk?

Let's plan meals your little ones will love. Call (647) 221-4333 or email hello@tinytummies.ca. We reply within 1 business day.

CallEmail